Scottwagnerhomes.com
  • Home
  • MLS Search
  • Communities
  • New Construction
  • Meet Scott
  • Contact Scott
  • Reviews
Login
Cell - (302) 727-1981 Office - (302) 360-0300

Sign in to your account

Need to reset your phone number?

Don't have an account with us?

Click here to sign up.

Paynters Mill Home Search

TO
Advanced Search

Address Search

Paynter's Mill Homes For Sale | Milton Real Estate

The Area

Welcome to Paynter's Mill in Milton, Delaware!  Paynter's Mill is conveniently located just off Route 1 at Cave Neck Road. Although it is a Milton address, Paynter's Mill is right on the border of Lewes and Milton and just a short 3.5 mile drive to the shops, restaurants, banking, and supermarket at The Villages of Five Points. If you want to enjoy the slower pace, historic charm, and outdoor activities in downtown Milton just make a left out of the neighborhood and drive 10 minutes!

The Development

Paynter's Mill is an actual village! Residents have their own small shopping center at the entrance to the development with a variety of shops and restaurants. The Colonial style village green and architecturally stunning clubhouse add to the character and charm of Paynter's Mill. The amenities include a pool, basketball court, clubhouse with fitness center, tennis court, playground, and walking trails. The grounds are impeccably maintained for the enjoyment of residents and visitors to the shops and restaurants.

The Homes

Paynter's Mill is a unique development with a variety of home styles and ownership options. You can choose from single level 1st or 2nd floor condominium units with 2 to 3 bedrooms and attached 1 or 2 car garages. Finding a condominium with an actual garage makes these units highly desirable.  Next are the single family condominiums.  If you are not familiar with the concept of single family condominiums, Contact Scott and ask for an explanation. Single family condominiums are perfect for the homeowner that wants the freedom of a condo without sharing walls with your neighbors!  Finally, Paynter's Mill has a variety of single family homes that are not condominium ownership. 

At this time there is only 1 single family home lot left to build! All condominium and single family condominium home sites are sold, but there are frequently resale opportunities available. 

To schedule your tour of Paynter's Mill, call Scott at (302) 727-1981 or Contact Scott and reference "Paynter's Mill" in your message!

All Paynters Mill Listings

16475 Howard Millman Ln, Milton image
16475 Howard Millman Ln, Milton $575,000

Click on virtual tour! Welcome to this beautifully crafted Schell Brothers home in the highly sought-after Paynters Mill community in Milton, Delaware. This spacious 4-be...

  • 4 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • DESU2116274 MLS
16466 Samuel Paynter Blvd, Milton image
16466 Samuel Paynter Blvd, Milton — Paynters Mill $459,900 ▼

End-Unit Carriage Home in Paynter’s Mill — Minutes from Lewes Beach Welcome to this beautifully maintained end-unit carriage home in the highly desirable, low-maintenance...

  • 4 Beds
  • 4 Baths
  • DESU2110138 MLS
  • Paynters Mill Bldg.
30847 E Annie Lank Ave Unit #1203, Milton image
30847 E Annie Lank Ave Unit #1203, Milton $449,900

Beautiful 3 Bedroom, 2 Bath Condo in Paynters Mill Welcome to this spacious second‑floor condo located in the highly sought‑after Paynters Mill community. Featuring 3 bed...

  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • DESU2103794 MLS
16433 Abraham Potter Run Unit #505, Milton image
16433 Abraham Potter Run Unit #505, Milton — Paynters Mill $320,000

Back on the Market but with a new price! Location says it all here: this 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom home sits inside Paynters Mill, one of the area's most amenity-rich communi...

  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • DESU2116132 MLS
  • Paynters Mill Bldg.
16299 John Rowland Trl Unit #1506, Milton image
16299 John Rowland Trl Unit #1506, Milton $314,900 ▼

Welcome to coastal living in the sought-after community of Paynter’s Mill in Milton! Just minutes from the Delaware beaches, this beautifully maintained 2-bedroom, 2-bath...

  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • DESU2111696 MLS
Like or Share

Address Search

Home Search

New Construction Developments

Foreclosure Search

Looking for something Unique in Milton?

  • Bay Front Properties - Milton
  • Broadkill Beach Properties - Milton
  • Lake and Pond Front Properties- Milton

Featured Milton Communities

  • Admirals Quarters
  • Anthem
  • Back Bay Cove
  • Bay Landing
  • Bridlewood
  • Broadkill Beach
  • Canaan Woods - Lincoln
  • Cannery Village
  • Captains Way - Ellendale
  • Cave Colony
  • Chestnut Crossing
  • Coolspring Manor
  • Covington Chase
  • Creek Falls Farm
  • Cripple Creek
  • Deep Branch Woods
  • Donovan Heritage
  • Eagle Crest
  • Estates at Carriage Springs
  • Estates at Milton Crossing
  • Heritage Creek
  • Heronwood
  • Holland Mills
  • Hunters Mill Estates
  • Lightship Cove
  • The Meadows of Beaver Creek
  • Oakridge
  • Osprey Landing
  • Overbrook Shores
  • Oyster Rock
  • Paynters Mill
  • Pemberton
  • Pintail Pointe
  • Pondview Estates
  • Poplar Grove
  • Preserve on the Broadkill
  • Prestwick
  • Primehook Beach
  • Quail Run
  • Red Fox Run
  • Reddenwood
  • Reserve at Fortune Field
  • River Rock Run
  • Sawmill Woods
  • Shipbuilders Village
  • Shoreview Woods
  • Spring Haven
  • Spring Town Farms
  • Starlight Meadows
  • Sunland Ranch
  • Sussex Meadows
  • Sylvan Acres
  • Vincent Overlook
  • The Vines of Sandhill
  • Wagamons West Shore
  • White Pine Cove
  • Windstone
  • Woodfield Preserve
  • Woodgate
  • Woodridge

Return To Milton Home Page

  • Milton Home Page

Search Featured Communities In Nearby Towns

  • Lewes
  • Rehoboth Beach
  • Dewey Beach
  • Bethany Beach
  • Millsboro
  • Home
  • MLS Search
  • New Construction
  • Meet Scott
  • Contact Scott
  • Communities

© 2026 | ScottWagnerHomes.com - All Rights Reserved

Scott Wagner is a Real Estate Agent Licensed in Delaware # RS-0022935

Scott Wagner, ABR - Realtor® | Keller Williams Realty
37169 Rehoboth Ave - Rehoboth Beach DE 19971
Office: 302-360-0300  Cell: 302-727-1981  

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website appears in part through the BRIGHT Internet Data Exchange program, a voluntary cooperative exchange of property listing data between licensed real estate brokerage firms in which Keller Williams Realty participates, and is provided by BRIGHT through a licensing agreement. The materials contained within this page may not be reproduced without express written consent of Keller Williams Realty. The information contained within this page is for personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Prospective purchasers should verify the information to their own satisfaction. All data is provided "AS-IS" and with all faults. All room dimensions and other measurements are approximate. Listings displayed on this website may no longer be available due to prior sale or removal from sale. Some real estate firms do not participate in the Internet Data Exchange and their listings do not appear on this site. Some properties listed with participating firms are not shown at the request of the seller.

All information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. © 2026 BRIGHT, All Rights Reserved.

Keller Williams Realty - Each Office Independently Owned and Operated.

     

  • Rehoboth Beach
  • Lewes
  • Milton
  • Millsboro
  • Bethany Beach
  • Dewey Beach
IDX Real Estate Websites by
, an FNF RE Tech Company • Accessibility • Terms • Privacy